Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Middleton's avatar

I doubted the Beatles and Lord of the Rings, however... my AI says:

Yes—essentially true. In the late 1960s, the Beatles seriously considered making The Lord of the Rings as their next film, with the commonly reported casting:

Paul McCartney — Frodo

Ringo Starr — Sam

George Harrison — Gandalf

John Lennon — Gollum

They reportedly approached Stanley Kubrick to direct, but Kubrick considered the book too difficult to film. J.R.R. Tolkien, who still controlled the film rights, also rejected the idea of the Beatles adapting it. Peter Jackson later confirmed the basic story after discussing it with McCartney.

There is a little uncertainty around exactly how firmly the roles had been settled—some early accounts describe the casting ideas shifting around—but the famous McCartney/Frodo, Starr/Sam, Harrison/Gandalf, Lennon/Gollum lineup is the best-known version.

It sounds preposterous now, but Lennon as Gollum is strangely easy to imagine. The film might have been either a psychedelic disaster or one of the most fascinating cultural artifacts ever made—possibly both.

That would have been quite a movie. Thanks for this tidbit to smile about. "Sargeant Pepper's Lord of the Rings Club Band."

David Burn's avatar

I love the Whitman factoids above, and the fact that his poetry disrupted the status quo and overturned the apple cart.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?